Forgot your password?
Error : Oops! If you are seeing this, your browser is not loading the page correctly. Please try pressing Control-F5 to force reload the page. If this doesn't work, you may need to update your browser :
Download Firefox | Download Chrome | Download IE
Your profile has been viewed

My Friends
My Bookmarks

BooksnLife 's notes

Indian men - a rare prototype? 4:04 pm UTC on September 24, 2013
It saddens me n gets me angry beyond reason to observe the disillusioned notion amongst a growing majority of Indian men about what it means to be a "man". The modern Indian man has somehow regressed back to being a selfish ape, one who puts his needs n desires first. He constantly has the "what's there in it for me" question running through his mind or a growing " I wanna eat all that appeals to my eye!" mentality. He wants to enjoy the  benefits without the hassle of duties. He is born with a sense of claim unlike his sister who is costantly provided a second hand treatment  and has somehow taught herself to bear it n be happy for her brother.  This specimen of our Indian man magnanimously opens the car door for the lady on a date, pays her bill, ensures he doesn't use any cuss word in her presence, indulges her for the evening n knows well how to shower a string of compliments on her or how to sweet talk her. He is generous enough to not show offence in case she makes a comment that hurts his ego n he's man enough to not as much as kiss her because hey it's the first date n no that's not the kind of thing a real man does. He does however feel intimidated around an intelligent girl, one who knows her mind and isn't exactly the kind of daughter in law his overbearing mom has in mind for him or better said her family. He naturally expects his wife to not be as qualified as him n earn lesser than him so he could enjoy the status of being the "breadwinner of the family".  For these very reasons there are several parents who refuse higher education to their girls. Moreover, this universal indian guy likes a chatty girl but the kind who mostly blabbers nonsense because that makes the girl appear somehow "cute" like "Sanaya" in Student of the Year or "Geet" in Jab we Met or "Khushi" in the soap opera "Iss Pyaar ko Kya Naam Doon".  All these women are rather likeable characters coz they are fair ( the indian definition for beautiful!, yes the colonial effect is indeed deep rooted and often seemingly beyond cure!) , loyal, super talkative n not exactly into books or the worldly affairs so to say. They are not just very sensitive as is often a given for every girl in the mind of a guy but are overtly dependent upon their men for their emotional sustenance. It disturbs me to see a growing acceptance and appeal for such characters especially that of Khushi amongst the Indian audiences particularly the housewives who  play a pivotal role in catapulting any soap opera to glory, thanks to the lull hours where they turn to TV to kill time before their beloved husbands return from their respective offices.

The truth , unfortunately, is that most of the men that at least I happen to have encountered in my short span of life know very little about responsibility,  accountability , character building n principles. Be it as brothers or fathers or sons, they aren't great example setteres ( the indian sons however do show an extreme attachment and sense of duty towards their mothers to a point where we often have a "Son's and Lover's" being rewritten in several households but then there too we see exceptions as is the law of nature) They don't act as men but grown up boys, boys who still yearn for the approval of their mothers, whose ego's are like balloons, one prick n boom it bursts, God knows what they'd do to avenge  their bruised pride, boys who are more stubborn than a 5 year old n who consider it rather manly to have random fits of anger wherein they choose to get aggressive with the girl in question be it their girlfried, wife, sister or mother , this aggressiveness may translate as  verbal or physical abuse depending upon how misfortunate the victim in question is , coz hey after all it's all a matter of ta-da ..chance, destiny  or being in the wrong place at the wrong time isn't it? And the victim (though they  are never looked upon in that way) musn't forget that this is the guys way of showing concern and affection n that she is being restricted ( in whatever way) for her own good because obviously the guy always, and unerringly so knows better don't you think? No one , at least most of the times has balls enough to condemn the brutal act of this ape as a cowardly way of exercising his superiority. On the contrary there are several districts, villages and even towns ( let's not rule out the educated illiterates please) where he who knows how to keep his women under control (be it again as stated earlier a mother , sister, girlfriend, grandmother and so on!) is deemed to be an honorable and wise man. These men can't cook for themselves, at least a majority still can't and are unwilling to help with the domestic chores n refuse outright saying that that's a girl's domain. Which of course reminds me of the clear demarcations they have in their minds about the distinguished roles of a girl and a guy. It does however suprise me to see how every other famous fashion designer,  tailor ,cook/chef, hair cutter, Radio Jockey, News Anchor, Actor, Singer - the seemingly girlish domains are copiously dominated by numerous men all across the country!

I have often tried asking myself this question but in vain and so I now turn to you in the hope of getting a reasonable response.  Why is there such a huge gap between the freedom we allow to the men vis a vis the freedom we "grant" to the women? Why can men do as they please n why must girls stay within certain boundaries? Does it boil down to the simple fact of a guy's inability to get pregnant that works in his favour n is often in the eyes of his family his alibi to indulge in illicit acts or is there more to it?? Where is the equality we speak of in our constitution?

I hope that at least some men out there feel ashamed by now about  the ignorance they reflect in matters such as approaching a girl if they like her , their idea being to just claim that girl by either  stalking, chasing, humiliating or at last raping her. I shudder to think the kind of mindsets more n more young Indian boys  are being raised with. What exactly has gone wrong with the upbringing? And please don't tell me it's the western influence! If anything I"m grateful for the exposure to the western culture which in turn has helped create a sense of comparison in the minds of zillions of us , thus enabling us to question and override several supersitious beliefs, stigmas and to broaden and enrichen our horizons, something that wouldn't have been possible if we were devoide of the knowledge of the lingua franca namely English  let alone other disadvantages!

Tell me this prey, how is it that no one pauses to question the upbringing of these boys who are so ruthlessly invoking havoc  in the lives of young girls n women be it through means of violence or emotional turmoil? What or who gives them the right to label a girl as sleazy or available just because she is wearing a skirt? Do they ever pause to think how it would feel if something as simple as their freedom to dress up as they wished were to be curtailed if it meant having their security under a threat? What if men were forbidden from smoking or drinking owing to the danger of being labeled characterless? What if they had to think twice before stepping out of the house n be constantly cautious of the time at which they leave n come back home? Do the men of my country have even the tiniest of awareness about how it feels to be stalked or to be letchered at? I know exceptions exist , as is true for any case and society but then what are these people who "understand" doing about it? No, you don't have to march out with hoards of people carrying vindictive slogans, nor must you create an NGO towards this cause or indulge in some other philanthropic act. I don't care if you make any of these grand gestures. But if you, young man, after reading my article become more mindful of your behaviour towards women, curtail yourself from looking upon them as sexual objects, treat not just the women in your family but also the one's you come across in your daily life with more respect, if you raise objection when a women is being exploited n offer support to her, if you show faith in a girl's intelligence n encourage her to study further n to handle the everyday hiccups on her own,  if you make a deliberate attempt to not stare piercingly at a girl when she's wearing shorts and don't act shocked or jump to conclusions when you see a woman in a bar or a seemingly male dominated area, then I would consider my purpose of writing this essay to have been served. I thank you and so do my sister's in india and world over.

They say that behind every successful man there's a woman. I say that this time we need you men behind us for this mission of creating gender sensitivity n equality shall fail without your support. We want  to be free , to feel like we can really breathe. We reach out to you for help.  Could you please cut away these fetters? I feel as if I would choke, we all do. Please hear my plea for help.

17 comments

at 5:41 pm UTC on September 24, 2013
I believe in my view whether its not the majority of the people say it or not, the situations has been really changing from the past. I've seen many women pursuing higher studies. This controlling the wives and physical or oral abuse and not helping in household activities that has also been changing. I dont know how many love marriages are being successful but those successful love married couple are really helping each one another in every aspect of life. And as a matter of fact you know it, the love marriages are also increasingly happening (irrespective or caste basis) with each and every year. But I agree the fact that coming onto an immediate conviction and labelling a girl as someone that has not been changing. And who in the hell is asking you to dress up traditionally? A lot of girls are wearing whatever they feel like and noone is objecting them. But at the end it is still predominantly male dominated. I accept the facts. Yup its all "being in the wrong place at the wrong time".
Delete

at 2:56 am UTC on September 25, 2013
I'm not trying to be optimistic but if you think it logically also changes has been happening. Struggle with time as usual throughout the history it will bring up alot of changes in the Indian's colonial and deep rooted beliefs.
Delete

at 11:31 am UTC on September 25, 2013
BRAVO, Mahima!!! First of all, I'm sorry I haven't made it to read and comment your article earlier. I wasn't online on interpals the last few days. I really love what you wrote and I am impressed by your self-confidence, honesty and fighting spirit! I can't really evaluate the situation you described in your article, as I never was in India before, but there are two things that showed me that it was just necessary that a girl stands up and read men the riot act. 1. In the last time the topic of sexual abuse and rape in India appeared in the German news with increased regularity. This made me think a lot about the safety of women in India - and of course I was worried about you. I also read about that topic in the newsletters of Amnesty Intnernational (I'm a member of that organization). 2. From time to time I get spams from Indian men here on Interpals. I don't want to judge Indian men, I also had male friends from that country in the past. But it shows that Indian men - besides Africans - more often interfere with woman than men from other places. I don't know if my comment was grammatically correct and whether the message was clear. I sometimes have problems to express myself well in English. In any case, I absolutely agree with your article and hope that Indian men will read and think about it. You should think about publishing it. India needs more tough women like you, Mahima :)
Delete

at 12:25 am UTC on September 27, 2013
I am honestly so amazed that you have written such a beautiful peace of work! I will tell you all my thoughts tomorrow my friend
Delete
BooksnLife 37Delhi
at 2:51 pm UTC on September 27, 2013
@kamalkorpati - You've put forth a very politically correct opinion I'd say. The men always have a hard time accepting apparently that something is really wrong with our system or the mind sets of our men. Maybe you feel that you're different n that's ok , actually that's great and I respect that, but please don't say that it actuallly IS all about being in "the wrong place at the wrong time" I had intended to use that line as a sarcasm , I don't believe in such a nonsensical fate. You are right, things have been changing but i believe they are NOT changing fast enough n have also been degrading over the past few years. You only need to read the incessant rape reports in the daily newspapers to understand that. And how in the world are colonialism n the injustice meted out to indian women at the hands of indian men connected? Unless of course you're trying to indirectly imply that Indian men have actually turned into colonisers ( ie the yhave internalised the colonial mentality) whereas the women of our nation are the colonised and hence the latter is constantly suppressed by the former?!?
Delete
BooksnLife 37Delhi
at 2:57 pm UTC on September 27, 2013
@aurora aka my darling Mimi - Wow I'm actually bereft of words, I'm not sure what to say to you save a humble Thank You!! Thanks for the generous encouragement. You don't have to be sorry silly, its totally fine, we get busy , life happens, I understand! ;) Thank you for your concern for me, it is indeed a genuine problem here n I have wondered about what women could do to safeguard themselves better. It is annoying to note the kind of image Indian men have created for themselves online to the extent that girls, including indian girls, ignore them like the plague. You know i'd probably try writing about that too, remind me later in case days have passed n I still haven't! Thank you for sharing those observations with me! You actually express yourself in a very clear n precise manner in English n so I doubt that you have to worry about your grammar n expression. ;)
Delete
BooksnLife 37Delhi
at 2:58 pm UTC on September 27, 2013
@ Langualover aka Seth : Thank You! I shall look forward to your comments/observations :)
Delete

at 10:39 am UTC on September 28, 2013
Mahima, you're amazing! I basically devoured what you've written, I loved it (don't get me wrong, I loved your style, your straightforwardness and your not afraid of saying what's on your mind). You asked in your essay why men in many societies find it natural that they have all the freedom, while women have all the responsibilities. I personally feel that there is some truth to what you said about women getting pregnant and men - not. I think it's ugly and wrong, but many men (and women) believe that a woman should be so clean and pure and "good" because she has a vagina, not a dick. I know people, who believe that all the sexual contacts that a woman has in her life leave some kind of genetic trace in her organizm, so when she finally meets a man she decides to have children with, her children will not only bear hers and her husband's genes, but genes of all the men she'd slept with before. WTF?? So, I think a lot of it has to do with a woman being a tool, an equipment that a man uses to produce the offspring. Then, I think, in the very very distant past, when physical strength meant more than other abilities, women were more useful in the house, they needed certain skills, to cook, to clean, etc. Men went hunting, went to war, they learnt different skills. They were outside, they saw more things, some of them started thinking, created science, while women were busy being pregnant and raising kids. The first schools were probably for boys for the same reason, by inertia - while 10 y.o. boys were at school, their 8 y.o. sisters were being married to someone. I'm just guessing here, but I think that the society was first dominated by men because of necessity, and then it just was more comfy this way, why to change things? And you're absolutely right - it's hard for a grown man to change his habits, a lot depends on how his parents and other family brough him up. Your generation of mothers will be more aware of this issue, I believe. Mothers are also "helping" the case, as you mentioned. Something like that is happening in Russia, only mothers bring up week, dependant men, who don't necessarily want to be dominant over their woman, but they also don't want to be rseponsible. It's easier this way. I think it's beautiful that women in India have been raising their voices. It's beautiful that some Indian men are supporting the women. I hope it will be getting better. I also think that India and Russia have two problems in common - corrupted government and corrupted police, and this too might be part of the issue.
Delete
M3rcury 39Dortmund
at 10:10 am UTC on September 29, 2013
I read a while ago that the greater the proportion of young men to old men and women in a country, the greater is the social instability, and cruelty. I think the key to changing men's behavior is to give women greater decision power in all areas, unfortunately a culture changes very slowly, decades ago women in my country also suffered under similar treatments, it takes time to change traditions and believes that have survived hundreds of years and are deeply imbedded in a society's consciousness, but eventually they will (not in our lifetime though.). Women have always had a civilizing influence on men, without them there would be no progress, it's sad that many countries are still 'socially backwards', repressing women, but ultimately we are the key to a more peaceful and loving world, and it is in everybody's interest to encourage their influence. Women are very powerful, as mothers, as wives, as sisters, we have the power to change a society, slowly, step by step, but first we'll need to change our own attitudes toward what it means to be a woman or a man. Don't let anyone hold you down, you are man's salvation!
Delete
vishav 35San Leandro
at 4:01 pm UTC on October 3, 2013
Well what you write in your note i have no point to disagree. And what i think is this is because of too much Illiteracy in India. And the main reason that i think is our so called Indian culture mentality because today their is no true culture exist and its a just a tool which people use to humiliate other or judge other. Like as in your message rape because of western culture or short dress and this is against Indian culture..i don't know where it is written its against Indian culture or what this things have to do with culture. And this so called culture is the only thing that is not helping India grow. People need to be more open mind and have broaden vision. It only comes with education. I read bhagat singh had called marriage without equality a legal form of prostitution and this shows his clarity about thoughts even in that time. Because he is literate. And we Indian say arrange marriages is our culture.. when a girl never see her husband before marriage and force to marry that is not culture that is legal prostitution. Without literacy we can't expect respect, patriotism, clarity of thoughts and neither we rise above from our religious conflicts. And by literacy i don't mean to be a engineer or doctor..its just be a human being and social that is true literacy.
Delete

at 3:38 pm UTC on October 9, 2013
@Mahima I dont agree that things have been degrading from the past. Is it because the rape incidents are being publicized through media and press you call the situations have been degrading? And is it for the reason because you are not aware of those similar situations in the past and believe that such things never happened before? And would you agree that if the media projects more and more people getting love married and leading a better life that you will change your opinion? It is not that i'm looking the world that as i wanted to see it. I'm just merely putting the facts i believe in. Is it because alot of youngsters protested against the government about women rights which has never done in the history you call the society been degrading? Okay i shouldn't have said that statement being in the wrong place at the wrong time. It is okay you dont believe in such nonsensical fate. Because you are more independent, bold and educated you have the complete freedom of what you want to do but not everyone has this opportunity outside there.
Delete
mariner82 43Širvintos
at 8:10 pm UTC on October 12, 2013
Nice article.well written............ The society undergoes changes and i believe as more and more ideas and thoughts influence our mindset,the rate of change will be fast as compared to what we think. Excellent example of understanding this effect is past demonstration bout Delhi rape case.it never happened in our society that people from north to south came on road to protest. The principle on which our society worked in past " sab chalta hai" is slowly dying out and i have observed at many occasions young generation go for "nahi chalta hai". if we leave big city's and move towards villages and districts.excellent example is customer kendra's functioning at root level.10 years back no one thought of having customer center (sewa kendra) at almost all tehsile's office.but, because some one thought of better governance and shared with other fellow members,thing got moving.the best part is witnessing the tabled views being implemented in our system. I also agree the move is bit slow,but what else i can ask for, if their is no improvement at all. Regarding gender inequality,that feeling existed centuries back and i m sure it will survive in many generations yet to come.but being a aware human being,we can amend the system for allowing a female to survive also in this system.With change of society from undivided family's to nuclear one's,the concept of giving privileges to male and responsibility's to females is slowly fading out. Now days i see sharing of both qualities to both genders.I can quote this with more and better conditions for girls to study and asking for their opinion for marriage and for male the feeling of taking care of kids while their better half is away for work and not feeling alien while entering in kitchen. We the so called modern and civilized people if don't take step to proceed on what we think,then their is no use to make more and more law's. All i can say is if we want to bring changes in our society,it starts from changing our mind.it not a problem that how far it has survived,the big question is how long we can survive with this attitude.its better to be updated Indians rather than outdated Indians. summarizing my words in one line " Revolution starts with me"
Delete

at 10:37 am UTC on October 29, 2013
A great piece of work! Well done Mahima :). I wish that our media would come up with such stories and encourage people who can pen down great thoughts which could help our society in amazing ways :(. It is very sad to see that our country is ruled by street dogs and males have always had the upper hand. Our society is still blinded by age old customs and traditions which are of no use. What has religion taught our fellow citizens? ?? Absolute shit!! How can a man bow his head to a goddess and at the same time hit the lady luck of his house??? We call a woman who comes into our family as "lakshmi" but treat her worst than a dog.... I do totally agree with your views Mahima. We do see some good changes though in our society but these are negligible in compared to rhe crime what's happening around us. Keep up the good work! We will support you :). God bless all those souls who have suffered hell in the hands of evil minded pigs!! I along with many fellow good samaritans of India wish to see India as a better place and as a safe haven for the future generations to come :).
Delete

at 8:16 pm UTC on October 29, 2013
This is the most informative article that I've read in a while: The writer revives those that have been condemned and buried by society....this reminds me of pre-Islamic practices of the Quraish tribes that lived in Mecca- who buried their daughters alive. Their crime was being born female. India is a soft power--if it's to make the next step of being one of the 'global players', then it must affect a change today. I believe that Indian men can do it! lets all pray for them. Amin
Delete

at 9:18 pm UTC on January 29, 2014
Are we all men NOT born out of a woman ? How come the mothers in the women do not see this in bringing their children ? Is it not the society responsible of this ? Are the women not responsible as much as the men ? I am not saying because i am an Indian but after travelling to umpteen countries my experience says the story is similar all over the world. Percentage may vary. Its the mindset which needs to change and i am afraid... the snail speed its changing its gonna take ages !!!!!
Delete
liberalthoughts 47Az Zawr
at 9:28 pm UTC on June 17, 2016
why are you so angry
Delete

at 8:39 am UTC on August 28, 2017
Hello BooknLife, I went through your note and thought to ask few questions. I assume you might be familiar with Hinduism where the Wealth, Education & Power are in hands of Goddess namely Laxmi, Saraswati & Kali. A culture which has the major factors shaping society in hands of a women cannot be biased towards women. Also, if you look at the practice of weddings, the ancient India had "Swayamvar" where the woman had right to decide her husband. So if you look from culture perspective, women always were worshipped & respected in this country's culture. Now,let us come to the present scenario where you have talked of the different treatment given to son's & daughters. Yes, it does exist in few cases and cannot be generalized to all the men. Just like one cannot generalize because of few women that all women are gold diggers. What needs to be introspected is what caused change in the culture from the ancient times to the present one's. Is it the unwanted effect of western feminism? Or is it the result of systematic brain-washing by the Macaulay's school which taught Indians to be ashamed of their own culture ? Or is it the education system which has not changed post Independence & has continued to brainwash generations into falsely believing that all western is good. The effect of education system will be felt in the society & even the family.
Delete
You are currently logged in from 216.73.216.221 View account activity.